So, I’m still going with my three weight loss apps (Noom, Weight Watchers, and MyFitness Pal). I figured I’d also talk about some online workout programs I’m trying since that goes along with my weight loss journey and may help others looking for the right fit.
I’m not going to lie…it’s a pain in the ass to log my meals into three different apps. But, someone I take great pleasure to log my exercise into all of the apps. I had some frustration with Noom early on, which prompted me to try the others, but in fairness, I was staying within my calories but also eating Oreos and crap. That might have been a contributing factor to why things weren’t moving.
I’ll again start with the positives.
Noom: I still find it easy to log my food. I learned that you can enter a recipe and then divide it up by portions. I was trying to figure that out on my own and winging it, which was likely way off. So that is helpful. It’s a little time-consuming to enter all the ingredients, but it works. If you choose a recipe from Noom, all the info is entered for you. I’ve tried two recipes and they have been decent. I’m making crab cakes from Noom tomorrow. I’ll keep you posted.
I have a little more trouble when I cook without a recipe, which is often. I’m Italian. My people don’t use recipes! We throw stuff together and it’s delicious. So I do end up entering it all manually and estimating how much I’m using. My coach would not approve.
The other positive is I really get to see what is a good choice vs a poor choice. It’s clear with their green, yellow, and red categories. You can have each, but you try and stay within a certain amount of calories per day in yellow and red. It’s fairly simple to follow. I also like the alerts if I forget to log something. I need the reminders nagging me to do stuff.
Weight Watchers: This program is easy to follow as well. There are a lot of foods that are zero points so you can fill up on fruit and vegetables to satisfy your hunger. There have been a few days that I have not finished my points. I’m not sure if that’s good or bad. I don’t have the plan with a coach or meetings. I’m trying to be as cost-effective as possible. The calorie range on all three apps is 1,200.
Weight Watchers has a lot of recipes and there are a lot of recipes online that give you the points. That definitely makes things easy. It’s also easy to enter your exercise and there are a lot more choices of exercises. For instance, I do Xtend Barre and there are barre workouts in Weight Watchers, where there are not in Noom.
I like that WW tracks my fitness minutes for the week. I can be impressed with myself and feel productive.
My Fitness Pal: This app has a lot more information about what you are eating, which is very interesting. It breaks down by carbs, protein, etc. It can go further and tell you which of the foods you logged are the best and worst for you, and it allows you to set daily goals. You can also track the time you are eating to see if you notice changes in your hunger if you are eating earlier or later. This app also tracks water, which for me is a huge plus. I’m terrible at remembering to drink my water and although I can log it in the other apps, it doesn’t track the ounces in the same way as MyFitness Pal. It’s a separate section to make sure you are drinking enough water.
With the paid version you get more features including the ability to upload your progress information to your computer. That’s not important to me, but it could be for you.
The negatives:
Noom: I don’t know how to say this nicely. I’m annoyed with my coach. I wanted my coach to offer suggestions. Instead, she says things like, “Do you have effective ways of measuring portions for your sweets?” And when I said that I’m not good at that because I really have trouble just having one and that’s my issue. She wrote back, “Do you have any other ideas?” Ummm…I kind of thought YOU might have some ideas for me because I paid a lot of money for some help not just for you to ask me what the hell I’m going to do to figure out how to eat fewer cookies. I’ve been less than impressed with the coaching aspect, and honestly, that’s one of the reasons I joined. The “group” that you are entered into when you join is another story. That is a very supportive place with people who all started at the same time as you, who are in the same point of the program. I have gotten more support there than I have from the coach.
Aside from that, I’m happy with the program. The daily things to read and do are sometimes too much. Sometimes they are helpful and you get some good tips and learn some scientifically based things. It’s interesting. Other times, it’s not super interesting.
Weight Watchers: I’m not signed up in any kind of group so I do miss the support from people that I have in Noom. To make up for that though, there is a Facebook group for WW, so I can make that work there and get my questions answered. At times it’s a little awkward to enter the food. I feel like I have to back and forth to be in the right place to enter meals. Maybe it’s just me, but it happens daily, so it’s a bit annoying at the start of each new day to find where I’m logging food.
I worry that I can eat too much on WW because of the zero point thing. Like what if I ate 15 pears? Or 15 bananas? That’s a lot of sugar. I don’t claim to understand it yet, but it’s not keto and I can eat fruit, so I’m good. I’m still trying to eat 2-3 fruits a day and not 15.
My Fitness Pal: I can see why people love this app due to the amount of info it tracks, but it takes a lot out of my life to enter the food. It’s just not as easy to enter the amount of food. Not everything is by tsp, tbsp, cup, etc. It can be by ounces and grams. That’s annoying. I don’t feel I’m accurate because of this. I’m not always in a place where I can measure.
There are a lot of exercises to add in this app, but many are listed singularly. Like back extensions. I mean I guess that would be great if I was going to the gym and track my sets, but right now and for the foreseeable future, I’m working out at home doing videos and weights.
I’m also using a few different workout apps. I have Beachbody, OpenFit, and YogaBurn. I like them all. I don’t use all of the workouts so I have to evaluate what I’m paying for. YogaBurn is workouts in 15-minute segments that you do 2-3 times. I prefer a 30-minute workout that doesn’t repeat, but her workout is very good.
With Beachbody, I do the 21-Day Fix and their yoga programs. I did the 3-week yoga retreat. If you are new to yoga, I highly recommend it. OpenFit…where to I begin. I have been doing Xtend Barre almost daily and I have a love/hate relationship with it. It looks easy. It’s not! There are some days I want to die and I have to stop for a minute, but then I keep going. The truth is, I really like it. The instructor (I feel terrible that I can’t think of her name but it’s 1AM and I’ll remember it for my next blog) is very upbeat…maybe a little too upbeat sometimes, but I feel like I accomplished something when I am done. My first week I thought I might die. Three weeks in, I’m doing much better. I still sometimes cheat and put my arms down or my heels down, but I need to do that less and less.
The truth is I like them all. For me, I like to have a choice. I have rheumatoid arthritis and some days, I can’t do Xtend Barre, and I need to just do a yoga stretching day. I’ve had about 4 of those. Other days I do more of a flow yoga or power yoga where you hold the poses and it’s hard. I like to mix it up.
My biggest success so far isn’t that I’m down 9lbs (because I don’t feel like I look any different AT ALL), it’s that I have worked out every day for the past 3 weeks without missing a workout. That’s huge for me. Take the baby steps! We can do this!
Send me a message or comment on my Facebook page. Let me know what app you’re using and why you like it. Recommend a workout, too!
Recent Comments